Over the past several years, Amazon’s Fulfillment-by-Amazon (“FBA”) service has become an enormously popular business model for international merchants looking to sell products online to U.S. customers. Under the FBA model, Amazon sellers store their products in one of Amazon's dozens of fulfillment centers across the United States, which then pick, pack and ship products to customers, as well as provide customer service, including product returns.
\r\nAmazon FBA has become so popular that it has actually restricted new merchants from sending inventory to fulfillment centers during this year’s fourth quarter because of capacity concerns leading up to this year’s holiday season.
\r\nWith every new business model that touches the U.S. market, there are a number of important tax issues that need be considered. The popularity of Amazon FBA has prompted both Amazon and its overseas merchants to try to fit the FBA model within the framework of the federal and state tax rules and regulations. The following are certain key U.S. federal and state tax considerations facing international merchants using Amazon’s FBA to sell products to U.S. customers.
\r\nFrom a state tax perspective, Amazon international sellers are potentially subject to two main methods of taxation – sales tax and income tax. The fundamental principle underlying a state’s right to tax transactions under both of these methods is “nexus,” which generally means the connection a taxpayer has to a particular state.
\r\nJust as state tax rates are determined on a state-by-state basis, so are the parameters of nexus. Some states focus on so-called “physical presence” (e.g., employees or property within the state), while others focus on so-called “economic presence” (e.g., a significant amount of sales within the state) or other factor methodologies. A layer of complexity is added by the fact that nexus is often defined differently for sales and income tax purposes. As a very general rule of thumb, states require a greater connection for income tax nexus than for sales tax nexus.
\r\nMost states generally take the position that third-party fulfillment centers do create sales tax nexus. As such, if a state has an Amazon FBA warehouse (more than two dozen states currently do), and your products are stored in such a warehouse, you’ll most likely be viewed as having nexus in that state and you’ll be required to register for a sales tax permit and collect and remit sales tax on sales to that state’s customers. Notable exceptions include Virginia and New York, which have specifically ruled that fulfillment centers do not create sales tax nexus in their respective states.
\r\nManaging sales tax obligations across many states can be challenging for international FBA sellers. To the taxpayer’s detriment, Amazon is known to be quite elusive about where it has fulfillment centers and where your particular product is stored at any one time. To Amazon’s credit, however, it does provide its online sellers with access to service providers and software that offer solutions that make sales tax compliance more manageable.
\r\nIn recent years, states have become increasingly aggressive in trying to impose taxes on online sellers. Some states, for instance, have reframed their method of taxation from an income tax into a broader “gross receipts tax” for the purpose of capturing more taxpayers within their nexus net. These states argue that while they are constitutionally restricted from imposing income taxes on businesses whose only contact with the state is soliciting sales (under a law known as P.L. 86-272), they are technically not so restricted with respect to non-income-based taxation.
\r\nIn a similar vein, in the international context, some have argued that constitutional protections against income taxation with respect to limited activities are meant to apply only in the context of interstate transactions and not in the case of international transactions.
\r\nIn the case of third-party fulfillment centers, Bloomberg BNA’s recently published Multistate State Tax Report for 2015 is instructive. In the report, senior state tax officials were surveyed on a variety of gray areas of state income and sales taxation, including the issue of third-party fulfillment services. While the survey rightfully disclaims that the responses should not be viewed as official state positions, they can be seen as giving a good indication as to each state’s general approach to the issues discussed.
\r\nIn the survey, state officials were asked specifically whether “unrelated third parties located in your state provid[ing] fulfillment services (i.e., fill product orders from corporate-owned inventory)” was a nexus-creating activity. Most state officials answered “yes,” and only a small minority (Oklahoma, Rhode Island and Vermont) answered “no.” The answers provided by the officials on this and other issues are indicative of the overall aggressive approach by most states in this and other controversial areas of state income taxation.
\r\nIn the case of Amazon FBA, unfortunately, Amazon seems to provide little direction for its online sellers regarding issues of state and local income taxation, and instead, caveats on its website that state and local income taxation obligations are solely the responsibility of the independent sellers.
\r\nDue to the complexities and uncertainties surrounding the state income tax implications of utilizing Amazon FBA, international sellers are often left with a difficult choice between taking a more conservative, but costly, approach that generally assumes nexus creation or a more aggressive, but risky, approach that generally assumes a lack of nexus under the Amazon FBA business model. Clear and official guidance by state taxing authorities would certainly be of significant help to today’s many uncertain taxpayers situated in the U.S. and abroad.
\r\nSimilar to state taxes, the extent to which the U.S. government can impose federal taxes on an international merchant depends greatly on the level of connectedness that the seller has to the U.S. Whereas “nexus” is the key principle in this regard in the area of state taxation, federal tax is triggered if the activities of a foreign seller in the U.S. rise to the level of a “U.S. trade or business” or “USTOB,” and the seller’s income is effectively connected to such U.S. trade or business.
\r\nIn the case that a foreign seller is resident in a country that has an income tax treaty with the U.S. (which generally trumps U.S. domestic law), a foreign seller’s U.S. business profits may be exempt from U.S. taxation so long as they are not attributable to a “permanent establishment” or “PE” in the U.S. The PE threshold is generally considered to be more taxpayer friendly than the USTOB threshold.
\r\nThe parameters of USTOB and PE have been the subject of decades of litigation in U.S. courts, which has at least led to the development of some judicial precedent in this area. More recently, in the international arena, the PE concept has been the main focus area of the recent so-called Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) project of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), with a special emphasis on today’s digital economy.
\r\nAt the risk of delving too deeply into a technical analysis, suffice it to say the Amazon FBA model may present USTOB or PE risks depending on the particular terms of an agreement between Amazon and the international seller. As a rule of thumb, the more an agreement represents an agency relationship, the greater the risk generally becomes.
\r\nCurrently, Amazon requires foreign online sellers to simply provide a Form W-8BEN to demonstrate their non-U.S. tax residency and avoid U.S. federal withholding tax. Interestingly, the Form W-8BEN is appropriate in cases where the foreign payee does not have income effectively connected with a USTOB. Amazon is careful, however, to include in its Amazon FBA agreements a tax indemnity clause stating that the seller acknowledges that storing products in its fulfillment centers may create tax nexus in any country, state, province or other locality in which the seller’s products are stored. It also says that it is the seller’s responsibility to fulfill any resulting tax obligations.
\r\nAs with state income tax, the tax characterization of the Amazon-to-seller relationship can have significant federal tax implications from both a substantive and reporting perspective. In an uncertain tax world, an international seller’s tax risk appetite will often be the guide to its ultimate approach.
\r\nPhoto credit: shutterstock.com/g/wawritto
\n","docType":"article","guid":"articles_b2999789b821c33e68bbf8d252b5cb58","lastModified":"2016-12-08T17:48:00.000Z","published":"2016-12-08T17:48:00.000Z","structuredData":null,"subtitle":"International sellers who rely on Amazon Fulfillment-by-Amazon need to know the tax code.","template":"legacy","title":"U.S. Tax Considerations for Amazon FBA International Sellers","type":"article","author":{"avatar":"https://staging.business.com/images/author/582/333ae3087b17f1bca78fd/100-100","bio":"After spending the majority of their respective careers at two of the largest accounting firms (PwC\r\nand Ernst & Young), Joshua Ashman (jashman@expattaxprofessionals.com) and Ephraim Moss\r\n(emoss@expattaxprofessionals.com) founded Expat Tax Professionals, a firm specializing in the\r\nneeds of U.S. citizens living abroad. You can visit the firm’s website at\r\nwww.expattaxprofessionals.com.","name":"Joshua Ashman Ephraim Moss","image":null,"slug":null,"social":{"facebook":"","linkedin":"","twitter":null,"website":"https://www.expattaxprofessionals.com/"},"status":"enabled","title":null,"type":"Old BDC Member","user":{"imagePath":"https://staging.business.com/images/uploads/user/profile/8a4dab23696c9114c98fde1a7a4579819bb4e.jpg","profile":{"company":"ExpatTax","jobTitle":"","website":"https://www.expattaxprofessionals.com/"}}},"breadcrumbs":null,"channels":{"primary":{"name":"Finance","slug":"finance"},"sub":{"name":"Finances","slug":"finances"}},"meta":{"robots":"index, follow","description":"International sellers using Amazon's FBA program should be aware of these U.S. tax implications.","title":"U.S. Tax Considerations for Amazon FBA International Se - business.com"},"parsedContent":{"toc":[{"id":"amazon-fba-and-state-taxation","title":"Amazon FBA and State Taxation"},{"id":"amazon-fba-and-federal-taxation","title":"Amazon FBA and Federal Taxation"}],"json":[{"component":"p","children":["Over the past several years, Amazon’s Fulfillment-by-Amazon (“FBA”) service has become an enormously popular business model for international merchants looking to sell products online to U.S. customers. Under the FBA model, Amazon sellers store their products in one of Amazon's dozens of fulfillment centers across the United States, which then pick, pack and ship products to customers, as well as provide customer service, including product returns."]},{"component":"p","children":["Amazon FBA has become so popular that it has actually ",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-10-11/amazon-said-to-limit-warehouse-access-to-new-merchants","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["restricted new merchants"]}," from sending inventory to fulfillment centers during this year’s fourth quarter because of capacity concerns leading up to this year’s holiday season."]},{"component":"p","children":["With every new business model that touches the U.S. market, there are a number of important tax issues that need be considered. The popularity of Amazon FBA has prompted both Amazon and its overseas merchants to try to fit the FBA model within the framework of the federal and state tax rules and regulations. The following are certain key U.S. federal and state tax considerations facing international merchants using Amazon’s FBA to sell products to U.S. customers."]},{"component":"h2","props":{"id":"amazon-fba-and-state-taxation"},"children":["Amazon FBA and State Taxation"]},{"component":"p","children":["From a state tax perspective, Amazon international sellers are potentially subject to two main methods of taxation – ",{"component":"em","children":["sales tax"]}," and ",{"component":"em","children":["income tax"]},". The fundamental principle underlying a state’s right to tax transactions under both of these methods is “",{"component":"em","children":["nexus"]},",” which generally means the connection a taxpayer has to a particular state."]},{"component":"p","children":["Just as state tax rates are determined on a state-by-state basis, so are the parameters of nexus. Some states focus on so-called “physical presence” (e.g., employees or property within the state), while others focus on so-called “economic presence” (e.g., a significant amount of sales within the state) or other factor methodologies. A layer of complexity is added by the fact that nexus is often defined differently for sales and income tax purposes. As a very general rule of thumb, states require a greater connection for income tax nexus than for sales tax nexus."]},{"component":"h3","children":["Sales Taxation"]},{"component":"p","children":["Most states generally take the position that third-party fulfillment centers do create sales tax nexus. As such, if a state has an Amazon FBA warehouse (more than two dozen states currently do), and your products are stored in such a warehouse, you’ll most likely be viewed as having nexus in that state and you’ll be required to register for a sales tax permit and collect and remit sales tax on sales to that state’s customers. Notable exceptions include Virginia and New York, which have specifically ruled that fulfillment centers do not create sales tax nexus in their respective states."]},{"component":"p","children":["Managing sales tax obligations across many states can be challenging for international FBA sellers. To the taxpayer’s detriment, Amazon is known to be quite elusive about where it has fulfillment centers and where your particular product is stored at any one time. To Amazon’s credit, however, it does provide its online sellers with access to service providers and software that offer solutions that make sales tax compliance more manageable."]},{"component":"h3","children":["Income Taxation"]},{"component":"p","children":["In recent years, states have become increasingly aggressive in trying to impose taxes on online sellers. Some states, for instance, have reframed their method of taxation from an income tax into a broader “gross receipts tax” for the purpose of capturing more taxpayers within their nexus net. These states argue that while they are constitutionally restricted from imposing income taxes on businesses whose only contact with the state is soliciting sales (under a law known as P.L. 86-272), they are technically not so restricted with respect to non-income-based taxation."]},{"component":"p","children":["In a similar vein, in the international context, some have argued that constitutional protections against income taxation with respect to limited activities are meant to apply only in the context of interstate transactions and not in the case of international transactions."]},{"component":"p","children":["In the case of third-party fulfillment centers, Bloomberg BNA’s recently published Multistate State Tax Report for 2015 is instructive. In the report, senior state tax officials were surveyed on a variety of gray areas of state income and sales taxation, including the issue of third-party fulfillment services. While the survey rightfully disclaims that the responses should not be viewed as official state positions, they can be seen as giving a good indication as to each state’s general approach to the issues discussed."]},{"component":"p","children":["In the survey, state officials were asked specifically whether “unrelated third parties located in your state provid[ing] fulfillment services (i.e., fill product orders from corporate-owned inventory)” was a nexus-creating activity. Most state officials answered “yes,” and only a small minority (Oklahoma, Rhode Island and Vermont) answered “no.” The answers provided by the officials on this and other issues are indicative of the overall aggressive approach by most states in this and other controversial areas of state income taxation."]},{"component":"p","children":["In the case of Amazon FBA, unfortunately, Amazon seems to provide little direction for its online sellers regarding issues of state and local income taxation, and instead, caveats on its website that state and local income taxation obligations are solely the responsibility of the independent sellers."]},{"component":"p","children":["Due to the complexities and uncertainties surrounding the state income tax implications of utilizing Amazon FBA, international sellers are often left with a difficult choice between taking a more conservative, but costly, approach that generally assumes nexus creation or a more aggressive, but risky, approach that generally assumes a lack of nexus under the Amazon FBA business model. Clear and official guidance by state taxing authorities would certainly be of significant help to today’s many uncertain taxpayers situated in the U.S. and abroad."]},{"component":"h2","props":{"id":"amazon-fba-and-federal-taxation"},"children":["Amazon FBA and Federal Taxation"]},{"component":"p","children":["Similar to state taxes, the extent to which the U.S. government can impose federal taxes on an international merchant depends greatly on the level of connectedness that the seller has to the U.S. Whereas “nexus” is the key principle in this regard in the area of state taxation, federal tax is triggered if the activities of a foreign seller in the U.S. rise to the level of a “U.S. trade or business” or “",{"component":"em","children":["USTOB"]},",” and the seller’s income is effectively connected to such U.S. trade or business."]},{"component":"p","children":["In the case that a foreign seller is resident in a country that has an income tax treaty with the U.S. (which generally trumps U.S. domestic law), a foreign seller’s U.S. business profits may be exempt from U.S. taxation so long as they are not attributable to a “permanent establishment” or “",{"component":"em","children":["PE"]},"” in the U.S. The PE threshold is generally considered to be more taxpayer friendly than the USTOB threshold."]},{"component":"p","children":["The parameters of USTOB and PE have been the subject of decades of litigation in U.S. courts, which has at least led to the development of some judicial precedent in this area. More recently, in the international arena, the PE concept has been the main focus area of the recent so-called Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"http://www.oecd.org/tax/transfer-pricing/BEPS-discussion-draft-on-the-attribution-of-profits-to-permanent-establishments.pdf","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["BEPS"]},") project of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), with a special emphasis on today’s digital economy."]},{"component":"p","children":["At the risk of delving too deeply into a technical analysis, suffice it to say the Amazon FBA model may present USTOB or PE risks depending on the particular terms of an agreement between Amazon and the international seller. As a rule of thumb, the more an agreement represents an agency relationship, the greater the risk generally becomes."]},{"component":"p","children":["Currently, Amazon requires foreign online sellers to simply provide a Form W-8BEN to demonstrate their non-U.S. tax residency and avoid U.S. federal withholding tax. Interestingly, the Form W-8BEN is appropriate in cases where the foreign payee does not have income effectively connected with a USTOB. Amazon is careful, however, to include in its Amazon FBA agreements a tax indemnity clause stating that the seller acknowledges that storing products in its fulfillment centers may create tax nexus in any country, state, province or other locality in which the seller’s products are stored. It also says that it is the seller’s responsibility to fulfill any resulting tax obligations."]},{"component":"p","children":["As with state income tax, the tax characterization of the Amazon-to-seller relationship can have significant federal tax implications from both a substantive and reporting perspective. In an uncertain tax world, an international seller’s tax risk appetite will often be the guide to its ultimate approach."]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"i","children":["Photo credit: shutterstock.com/g/wawritto"]}]}]},"resource":null,"sponsorship":null,"thumbnail":{"path":null,"caption":"Utah778 / Getty Images","isBlurred":true},"bestPicks":null},"related":{"relatedArticles":[{"title":"U.S. Tax Considerations for Amazon FBA International Sellers","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/ephraim-moss-and-joshua-ashman-taxes-amazon-fba-international/","slug":"ephraim-moss-and-joshua-ashman-taxes-amazon-fba-international","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/channel/finance.jpg","dek":"International sellers who rely on Amazon Fulfillment-by-Amazon need to know the tax code.","lastModified":"2016-12-08T17:48:00Z","published":"2016-12-08T17:48:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"5 Common Retail Scams: How to Spot and Stop Them","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/stop-common-retail-fraud-and-theft/","slug":"stop-common-retail-fraud-and-theft","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/5d0/190325a215e291b8b4578/1500-0-","dek":"How to prevent your retail employees from stealing from you","lastModified":"2017-12-06T08:00:00Z","published":"2017-12-06T08:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"Restaurant Security: A Guide to Getting Your Money's Worth","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/restaurant-security-guide/","slug":"restaurant-security-guide","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/58a/dced22f87b17e076bf981/1500-0-","dek":"It's hard to determine the ROI you will get from increasing your restaurant security.","lastModified":"2019-07-31T20:42:54Z","published":"2017-02-21T08:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Restaurant Security: A Guide to Getting Your Money's Worth","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/restaurant-security-guide/","slug":"restaurant-security-guide","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/58a/dced22f87b17e076bf981/1500-0-","dek":"It's hard to determine the ROI you will get from increasing your restaurant security.","lastModified":"2017-02-21T08:00:00Z","published":"2017-02-21T08:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"State of the Retail Industry in 2017","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/state-of-retail-industry/","slug":"state-of-retail-industry","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/590/77b213087b18507b605f1/1500-0-","dek":"Things are changing, but it's not all doom and gloom.","lastModified":"2017-05-18T17:00:00Z","published":"2017-05-18T17:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"How to Cash in on Your Excess Inventory","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/cash-excess-inventory/","slug":"cash-excess-inventory","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/5d6/ffca25a215e710d8b4581/1500-0-","dek":"Excess inventory doesn't have to be a problem if you know what to do with it.","lastModified":"2019-09-09T12:20:00Z","published":"2019-09-09T12:20:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"Hiring for Retail: A Guide to Building the Right Team","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/retail-hiring-guide/","slug":"retail-hiring-guide","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/594/85c791039eb45268b4572/1500-0-","dek":"It starts with the interview and ends with you.","lastModified":"2017-07-12T07:00:00Z","published":"2017-07-12T07:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"That Was Easy: How to Make Payment Effortless for Clients","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/how-to-make-the-payment-process-easier-for-clients/","slug":"how-to-make-the-payment-process-easier-for-clients","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/5eb/413f25a215e23318b456c/1500-0-","dek":"The ideal payment processes are rooted in the preferences of your customer – not those of your staff, or even your ideal business model.","lastModified":"2020-05-08T17:19:00Z","published":"2015-10-08T13:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"Should Your Business Accept Bitcoin?","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/should-your-business-accept-bitcoin/","slug":"should-your-business-accept-bitcoin","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/542/07ea5cb786b255c8b45d1/1500-0-","dek":"Dish Network is the first major company to accept Bitcoin. Should your business follow suit? We take a look at the pros and cons.","lastModified":"2014-09-23T19:00:00Z","published":"2014-09-23T19:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Managing Your Restaurant – A Guide","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/managing-restaurant/","slug":"managing-restaurant","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/58c/afbad2f87b13d55f0ae03/1500-0-","dek":"There is a lot to restaurant management, whether you manage it yourself or hire managers.","lastModified":"2019-07-31T20:52:46Z","published":"2017-03-17T20:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Managing Your Restaurant – A Guide","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/managing-restaurant/","slug":"managing-restaurant","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/58c/afbad2f87b13d55f0ae03/1500-0-","dek":"There is a lot to restaurant management, whether you manage it yourself or hire managers.","lastModified":"2017-03-17T20:00:00Z","published":"2017-03-17T20:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"Fashion Forward: Top 10 Retail Trends for 2016","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/fashion-forward-top-10-retail-trends-for-2016/","slug":"fashion-forward-top-10-retail-trends-for-2016","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/567/191e43187b19f268b457d/1500-0-","dek":"We foresee big changes for retail this new year. Here's a list of 10 trends to keep you up to date on the ever-evolving industry.","lastModified":"2017-02-22T23:52:24Z","published":"2015-12-21T18:00:00Z","sponsored":null}],"relatedReviews":[{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5e46e2fc5a215eab4d8b457c/taxes_pano_Prostock-Studio_getty.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/best-tax-debt-relief-services/","title":"The Best Tax Debt Relief Services of 2021","dek":"Looking for the best tax debt relief service? We have easy-to-read, unbiased expert reviews and feature comparisons of the best and cheapest services.","slug":"best-tax-debt-relief-services","lastModified":"2021-03-23T20:42:00Z"},{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5dfbca819c658adc118b4568/Payroll_AndreyPopov_Getty.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/online-payroll-services/","title":"The Best Online Payroll Services of 2021","dek":"Our team has compared the best online payroll services for 2021. See up-to-date reviews and costs for the top services.","slug":"online-payroll-services","lastModified":"2021-03-19T20:05:00Z"},{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5df3d8695a215e58428b4570/POS_GETTY_DERO2084.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/best-pos-systems/","title":"The Best POS Systems of 2021","dek":"Before you choose a POS system, check out our reviews of the best picks for 2021. ","slug":"best-pos-systems","lastModified":"2021-03-17T17:33:00Z"}],"relatedSponsoredArticles":null}},"pageContext":{"displayModified":"2016-12-08T17:48:00.000Z","template":"legacy","title":"U.S. Tax Considerations for Amazon FBA International Sellers","meta":{"robots":"index, follow"},"docType":"articles","slug":"ephraim-moss-and-joshua-ashman-taxes-amazon-fba-international","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/ephraim-moss-and-joshua-ashman-taxes-amazon-fba-international/","skipTOC":false}},"staticQueryHashes":[]}