For many business owners, search term advertising has become a tried and true part of their marketing efforts to obtain new business. Keyword or Search Term advertising refers to results that appear alongside or above search results in response to terms (\"keywords\") that a user entered into the search box.
\r\nSometimes, search results are easily identifiable and labeled as “Ads,” but other times, search results will appear as part of the initial search query, and the order in which they appear is largely connected to dollar amount the business spent on being associated with certain search terms.
\r\nFor example, a search for “contact lenses” may lead to paid ads for specific online contact lens retailers followed by or alongside the normal search results for the terms in the search engine.
\r\nTypically, linking the results of a users’ query to your business does not pose any problems when you have chosen generic, everyday words that are associated with your brand or product. Where an issue may pose problems in terms of keyword searches is when you designate a registered trademark as part of the keywords that automatically link to your website or product (see 1-800 Contacts Inc., v. Lens.com, Inc.) and/or you use a trademarked term in your advertisement.
\r\nIn such cases, business owners should tread carefully to avoid any trademark infringement lawsuits.
\r\nIn an action for trademark infringement, the Plaintiff (typically, the Trademark owner), must show four elements. That the Plaintiff:
\r\nSince 2009, all federal district courts have held that the purchase of another party’s trademark as a keyword to trigger an advertisement constitutes “use in commerce.” The main question, therefore, is whether such a use is likely to cause confusion as to the source or affiliation of the good or service. In some circumstances, courts have found the advertisers (ie. Businesses) that buy trademarked keywords liable for infringement.
\r\nTo determine liability, courts usually consider four main factors:
\r\nThe most important factor, however, is the context and content of the keyword advertisement. The context of the ad is viewed in terms of the results page architecture: are paid ads differentiated from unpaid search results?
\r\nIf yes, then consumers are more likely to understand that ads may come from sources other than the trademark owner, even if they used the trademark as a search term in the first place. The content of the ad is also extremely important. The following examples illustrate what is and what is not acceptable:
\r\nRelated Article: Keyword Research Hacks For the Most Important Part of Content Marketing
\r\nAcademyOne bought the keyword “CollegeSource,” which was its competitor’s trademark, to be linked to its own website in search results
\r\nAcademyOne’s ad appeared when a user typed in “collegesource” into the search engine, but its ad, which appeared at the top of the results page, only included “College Transfer Help” or “Find Transfer Information” and the domain name “collegetransfer.net.” The ad itself did not include CollegeSource’s trademarks.
\r\nNo Infringement. The Court stated that AcademyOne’s ads were clearly presented to consumers in light of “the entire context of the advertisement’s appearance, especially the clearly differentiated [Sponsored Link] text boxes and the fact that CollegeSource’s name does not appear within the language of AcademyOne’s advertisement.”
\r\nRelated Article: The Copyright Question: The Difference Between Inspiration and Infringement
\r\nArmstrong Steel bought its competitor’s, General Steel, trademark “General Steel” to use in keyword searches and also used it in its advertisement.
\r\n“Don’t Buy General Steel Without Pricing Armstrong First. Price a Steel Building in Minutes! www.ArmstrongSteelBuildings.com”
\r\nNo Infringement. The Court said that “While Armstrong was using the term to refer to plaintiff’s company, the Court does not find the record supports the finding that such use was likely to cause confusion among consumers in light of all of the surrounding information that identified Armstrong Steel as the source of the website and distinguished Armstrong Steel from General Steel.\"
\r\nSnuggly Plushez bought the trademarked term “Pillow Pets” to use in keyword search results and used the registered trademark of CJ Products in its advertisements.
\r\n“Official PillowPets.CO- Soft Chenille Plush Pillow Pets Low Prices, New Styles Now in stock www.pillowpets.co”
\r\nInfringement. The Defendant used the trademark in its ad and built its business name and website around its competitor’s trademark. Additionally, because Snuggly Plushez created knock-off versions of the Plaintiff’s “pillow pets,” the Court found actual confusion created by the Defendants, instead of the likelihood of confusion.
\r\nIn the end, buying trademarked keywords may or may not constitute infringement—liability largely turns on the content of the advertisement.
\r\nThe main points you should take away are:
\r\nAlthough most keyword lawsuits fail (they are rarely worth the litigation costs), always consult with an experienced Trademark attorney to go over your possible risks and ad strategies.
\n","docType":"article","guid":"articles_7c29ffb56a807adfdd02ac173a1522a8","lastModified":"2015-09-24T19:00:00.000Z","published":"2015-09-24T19:00:00.000Z","structuredData":null,"subtitle":null,"template":"legacy","title":"Can I Use a Competitor’s Trademarked Words in Keyword Advertising?","type":"article","author":{"avatar":null,"bio":"Daliah Saper is a Chicago based intellectual property, media, and business attorney that has handled many high profile cases (including one she argued before the Illinois Supreme Court). Daliah is regularly interviewed on national tv, radio, and in several print publications including Fox News, CNBC, ABC News, and The New York Times. She is the recipient of several prestigious awards including a 40 under 40 recognition by Law Bulletin Publishing Company. For the past 5 years, Daliah has served as an Adjunct Professor at Loyola University Chicago School of Law teaching Entertainment Law; she has also taught Internet Law as an Adjunct Professor at the University of Illinois College of Law. As a litigator she handles cases involving trademark and copyright infringement, domain names, trade secret misappropriation, right of publicity, defamation, and commercial disputes. As a transactional lawyer she helps clients choose the right business entity, drafts bylaws and operating agreements, negotiates terms of use, privacy policies, software licenses and other contracts, and provides comprehensive trademark and copyright counseling. Full bio available at: http://saperlaw.com/attorneys/","name":"Daliah Saper","image":null,"slug":null,"social":{"facebook":"https://www.facebook.com/saperlawoffices","linkedin":"https://www.linkedin.com/company/1531826?trk=tyah","twitter":"https://twitter.com/saperlaw","website":"http://www.saperlaw.com"},"status":"enabled","title":null,"type":"Old BDC Member","user":{"imagePath":"https://staging.business.com/images/undefined","profile":{"company":"Christie Communications","jobTitle":"Senior Strategist","website":""}}},"breadcrumbs":null,"channels":{"primary":{"name":"Human Resources","slug":"human-resources"},"sub":{"name":"HR Solutions","slug":"hr-solutions"}},"meta":{"robots":"index, follow","description":"Learn from these lawsuits to prevent trademark infringement caused from keyword search teams and advertisements.","title":"Legalities in Keyword Advertising - business.com"},"parsedContent":{"toc":[],"json":[{"component":"p","children":["For many business owners, search term advertising has become a tried and true part of their marketing efforts to obtain new business. Keyword or Search Term advertising refers to results that appear alongside or above search results in response to terms (\"keywords\") that a user entered into the search box. "]},{"component":"p","children":["Sometimes, search results are easily identifiable and labeled as “Ads,” but other times, search results will appear as part of the initial search query, and the order in which they appear is largely connected to dollar amount the business spent on being associated with certain search terms. "]},{"component":"p","children":["For example, a search for “contact lenses” may lead to paid ads for specific online contact lens retailers followed by or alongside the normal search results for the terms in the search engine. "]},{"component":"p","children":["Typically, linking the results of a users’ query to your business does not pose any problems when you have chosen generic, everyday words that are associated with your brand or product. Where an issue may pose problems in terms of keyword searches is when you designate a registered trademark as part of the keywords that automatically link to your website or product (see ",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"https://www.ca10.uscourts.gov/opinions/11/11-4114.pdf","target":"_blank","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["1-800 Contacts Inc., v. Lens.com, Inc.)"]}," and/or you use a trademarked term in your advertisement. "]},{"component":"h3","children":[{"component":"em","children":["What Are the Rules?"]}]},{"component":"p","children":["In such cases, business owners should tread carefully to avoid any trademark infringement lawsuits. "]},{"component":"p","children":["In an action for trademark infringement, the Plaintiff (typically, the Trademark owner), must show four elements. That the Plaintiff:"]},{"component":"ol","children":[{"component":"li","children":["Owns a valid trademark,"]},{"component":"li","children":["Has prior rights in the trademark,"]},{"component":"li","children":["The Defendant used the Plaintiff's trademark in commerce in connection with the sale of goods or services, and lastly"]},{"component":"li","children":["That the Defendant’s use of the Plaintiff’s mark causes a likelihood of confusion about product source, or affiliation with the Plaintiff. "]}]},{"component":"p","children":["Since 2009, all federal district courts have held that the purchase of another party’s trademark as a keyword to trigger an advertisement constitutes “use in commerce.” The main question, therefore, is whether such a use is likely to cause confusion as to the source or affiliation of the good or service. In some circumstances, courts have found the advertisers (ie. Businesses) that buy trademarked keywords liable for infringement. "]},{"component":"h3","children":[{"component":"em","children":["What Does the Court Consider?"]}]},{"component":"p","children":["To determine liability, courts usually consider four main factors:"]},{"component":"ol","children":[{"component":"li","children":["The strength of the mark,"]},{"component":"li","children":["The evidence of actual confusion,"]},{"component":"li","children":["The type of goods and degree of care likely to be exercised by the purchaser, and most importantly"]},{"component":"li","children":["The labeling and appearance of the advertisements and the surrounding context on the web page."]}]},{"component":"p","children":["The most important factor, however, is the context and content of the keyword advertisement. The context of the ad is viewed in terms of the results page architecture: are paid ads differentiated from unpaid search results?"]},{"component":"p","children":["If yes, then consumers are more likely to understand that ads may come from sources other than the trademark owner, even if they used the trademark as a search term in the first place. The content of the ad is also extremely important. The following examples illustrate what is and what is not acceptable: "]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Related Article: "]},{"component":"Link","props":{"href":"http://www.business.com/seo-marketing/keyword-research-hacks-to-get-you-found-and-read-online/"},"children":["Keyword Research Hacks For the Most Important Part of Content Marketing"]}]},{"component":"h3","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Example 1: ",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCOURTS-paed-2_10-cv-03542/pdf/USCOURTS-paed-2_10-cv-03542-4.pdf","target":"_blank","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["CollegeSource Inc., v. AcademyOne Inc."]}]}]},{"component":"p","children":["AcademyOne bought the keyword “CollegeSource,” which was its competitor’s trademark, to be linked to its own website in search results"]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Advertisement"]}]},{"component":"p","children":["AcademyOne’s ad appeared when a user typed in “collegesource” into the search engine, but its ad, which appeared at the top of the results page, only included “College Transfer Help” or “Find Transfer Information” and the domain name “collegetransfer.net.” The ad itself did not include CollegeSource’s trademarks. "]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Ruling"]}]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"em","children":["No Infringement."]}," The Court stated that AcademyOne’s ads were clearly presented to consumers in light of “the entire context of the advertisement’s appearance, especially the clearly differentiated [Sponsored Link] text boxes and the fact that CollegeSource’s name does not appear within the language of AcademyOne’s advertisement.”"]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Related Article: "]},{"component":"Link","props":{"href":"http://www.business.com/legal/the-copyright-question-the-difference-between-inspiration-and-infringement/"},"children":["The Copyright Question: The Difference Between Inspiration and Infringement"]}]},{"component":"h3","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Example 2: ",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"http://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1382&context=historical","target":"_blank","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["General Steel Co., v. Armstron Steel Co."]}]}]},{"component":"p","children":["Armstrong Steel bought its competitor’s, General Steel, trademark “General Steel” to use in keyword searches and also used it in its advertisement."]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Advertisement"]}]},{"component":"p","children":["“Don’t Buy General Steel Without Pricing Armstrong First. Price a Steel Building in Minutes! www.ArmstrongSteelBuildings.com”"]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Ruling"]}]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"em","children":["No Infringement."]}," The Court said that “While Armstrong was using the term to refer to plaintiff’s company, the Court does not find the record supports the finding that such use was likely to cause confusion among consumers in light of all of the surrounding information that identified Armstrong Steel as the source of the website and distinguished Armstrong Steel from General Steel.\""]},{"component":"h3","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Example 3: ",{"component":"a","props":{"href":"https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2115565/cj-products-llc-v-snuggly-plushez-llc/","target":"_blank","rel":"nofollow"},"children":["CJ Products LLC v. Snuggly Plushez LLC"]}]}]},{"component":"p","children":["Snuggly Plushez bought the trademarked term “Pillow Pets” to use in keyword search results and used the registered trademark of CJ Products in its advertisements."]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Advertisement"]}]},{"component":"p","children":["“Official PillowPets.CO- Soft Chenille Plush Pillow Pets Low Prices, New Styles Now in stock www.pillowpets.co”"]},{"component":"h4","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Ruling"]}]},{"component":"p","children":[{"component":"em","children":["Infringement."]}," The Defendant used the trademark in its ad and built its business name and website around its competitor’s trademark. Additionally, because Snuggly Plushez created knock-off versions of the Plaintiff’s “pillow pets,” the Court found actual confusion created by the Defendants, instead of the likelihood of confusion."]},{"component":"p","children":["In the end, buying trademarked keywords may or may not constitute infringement—liability largely turns on the content of the advertisement. "]},{"component":"p","children":["The main points you should take away are:"]},{"component":"ol","children":[{"component":"li","children":["If you are using a competitor's trademark in a keyword search, try to make your ad or web page link as distinguishable as possible from your competitor, so that users are clear they are not visiting your competitors website."]},{"component":"li","children":["Try not to use your competitor’s marks or business name in your ad, but if you do, only do it to compare and"]},{"component":"li","children":["Clearly identify the source of the ad by including your company name in the ad. "]}]},{"component":"p","children":["Although most keyword lawsuits fail (they are rarely worth the litigation costs), always consult with an experienced Trademark attorney to go over your possible risks and ad strategies. "]}]},"resource":null,"sponsorship":null,"thumbnail":{"path":null,"caption":"Monkeybusinessimages / Getty Images","isBlurred":true},"bestPicks":null},"related":{"relatedArticles":[{"title":"Can I Use a Competitor’s Trademarked Words in Keyword Advertising?","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/legalities-around-using-competitors-trademarked-words-in-search-terms-and-keyword-advertising/","slug":"legalities-around-using-competitors-trademarked-words-in-search-terms-and-keyword-advertising","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/channel/human-resources.jpg","dek":"Learn from these lawsuits to prevent trademark infringement caused from keyword search teams and advertisements.","lastModified":"2015-09-24T19:00:00Z","published":"2015-09-24T19:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"Burgers, Burritos and Brand Names: Tasty Burger vs. Chipotle","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/burgers-burritos-and-brand-names-tasty-burger-vs-chipotle/","slug":"burgers-burritos-and-brand-names-tasty-burger-vs-chipotle","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/57d/c4d4b3087b14d13238478/1500-0-","dek":"Breaking down trademark law. Here's what the Tasty Burger vs. Chipotle dispute can teach us about trademark infringement.","lastModified":"2016-09-19T17:00:00Z","published":"2016-09-19T17:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"What to Do if a Major Corporation Steals Your Trademark","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/what-to-do-if-a-major-corporation-steals-your-trademark/","slug":"what-to-do-if-a-major-corporation-steals-your-trademark","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/channel/marketing.jpg","dek":"Taking Action When a Major Corporation Steals Your Trademark","lastModified":"2015-11-11T23:00:00Z","published":"2015-11-11T23:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"The In-N-Out Effect: Trademark Mistakes You Need to Avoid","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/4-trademark-mistakes-you-need-to-avoid/","slug":"4-trademark-mistakes-you-need-to-avoid","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/channel/business-basics.jpg","dek":"Next time you order \"Animal Style\" fries, think about the importance of trademarks. Avoid these trademark mistakes before it's too late.","lastModified":"2015-03-16T17:00:00Z","published":"2015-03-16T17:00:00Z","sponsored":false},{"title":"The In-N-Out Effect: Trademark Mistakes You Need to Avoid","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/4-trademark-mistakes-you-need-to-avoid/","slug":"4-trademark-mistakes-you-need-to-avoid","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/550/6e74b3187b10a768b4568/1500-0-","dek":"Next time you order \"Animal Style\" fries, think about the importance of trademarks. Avoid these trademark mistakes before it's too late.","lastModified":"2019-07-31T20:57:54Z","published":"2015-03-16T17:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"What to Do if a Major Corporation Steals Your Trademark","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/what-to-do-if-a-major-corporation-steals-your-trademark/","slug":"what-to-do-if-a-major-corporation-steals-your-trademark","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/564/23da73087b117658b4571/1500-0-","dek":"You don't have to let them get away with it. Here are tips for what to do if a major corporation steals your trademark.","lastModified":"2017-02-22T23:53:14Z","published":"2015-11-11T23:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Protect Your Ideas: How to Stay Away From Trademark Infringement","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/protect-your-business-from-trademark-infringement/","slug":"protect-your-business-from-trademark-infringement","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/54e/ec40f2f87b178568b45b2/1500-0-","dek":"What can pomegranate juice teach you about trademark infringement? Quite a lot actually. Find out more in this article.","lastModified":"2015-02-26T18:00:00Z","published":"2015-02-26T18:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Search Intent: Look to Your SEO Teams to Get the Why Behind Searches","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/search-intent-look-to-your-seo-teams-to-get-the-why-behind-searches/","slug":"search-intent-look-to-your-seo-teams-to-get-the-why-behind-searches","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/56b/ce2573087b181409b7991/1500-0-","dek":"Do you understand why people search the way they do? Learn the intent behind searchers to maximize your SEO.","lastModified":"2016-02-15T16:00:00Z","published":"2016-02-15T16:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Lessons in SEO Oversight: Don't Ignore the Long Tail","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/lessons-in-seo-oversight-dont-ignore-the-long-tail/","slug":"lessons-in-seo-oversight-dont-ignore-the-long-tail","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/56b/b71f93287b1e0351fe0b5/1500-0-","dek":"Long tail keywords are an important part of every SEO strategy, yet they often get ignored. Use this guide to find your low hanging fruit.","lastModified":"2016-02-10T22:00:00Z","published":"2016-02-10T22:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Step-by-Step Guide: How to Use SEO to Increase Your Content Value","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/how-to-use-seo-to-increase-your-content-value/","slug":"how-to-use-seo-to-increase-your-content-value","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/56e/381773287b1ea635b522e/1500-0-","dek":"It takes more than quality to get your content noticed by search engines, and therefore, readers. Incorporating best SEO practices is key.","lastModified":"2016-03-17T13:00:00Z","published":"2016-03-17T13:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Are Hashtags Intellectual Property?","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/are-hashtags-intellectual-property/","slug":"are-hashtags-intellectual-property","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/content/558/415f13087b172238b4589/1500-0-","dek":"Hashtags have taken over social media and trademarking a hashtag can boost consumer engagement with your business.","lastModified":"2017-02-22T23:53:13Z","published":"2015-06-19T13:00:00Z","sponsored":null},{"title":"Are Hashtags Intellectual Property?","canonical":"https://www.business.com/articles/are-hashtags-intellectual-property/","slug":"are-hashtags-intellectual-property","thumbnail":"https://www.business.com/images/content/5d0/cfb325a215e30628b456d/1500-0-","dek":"Hashtags began on Twitter and have now spread to other major social media websites like Facebook, Google+ and Instagram—and to communication in general.","lastModified":"2015-06-19T13:00:00Z","published":"2015-06-19T13:00:00Z","sponsored":false}],"relatedReviews":[{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5e00ccda9c658a423d8b4569/HR_People_fizkes_Getty.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/best-peo-services/","title":"The Best PEO Service Providers of 2021","dek":"Professional employer organization services can simplify your human resource responsibilities. Learn about the best PEOs available for your small business.","slug":"best-peo-services","lastModified":"2021-03-23T19:45:00Z"},{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5dfbca819c658adc118b4568/Payroll_AndreyPopov_Getty.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/online-payroll-services/","title":"The Best Online Payroll Services of 2021","dek":"Our team has compared the best online payroll services for 2021. See up-to-date reviews and costs for the top services.","slug":"online-payroll-services","lastModified":"2021-03-19T20:05:00Z"},{"doc_type":"category","thumbnail":"https://staging.business.com/images/rz/5d85356c7b43745d448b458d/hroutsourcing_fizkes.jpg","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/categories/best-hr-outsourcing-services/","title":"The Best HR Outsourcing Services of 2021","dek":"Human resource outsourcing services can simplify your human resource responsibilities. Learn about the best HROs available for your small business.","slug":"best-hr-outsourcing-services","lastModified":"2021-03-11T17:15:00Z"}],"relatedSponsoredArticles":null}},"pageContext":{"displayModified":"2015-09-24T19:00:00.000Z","template":"legacy","title":"Can I Use a Competitor’s Trademarked Words in Keyword Advertising?","meta":{"robots":"index, follow"},"docType":"articles","slug":"legalities-around-using-competitors-trademarked-words-in-search-terms-and-keyword-advertising","canonical":"https://staging.business.com/articles/legalities-around-using-competitors-trademarked-words-in-search-terms-and-keyword-advertising/","skipTOC":false}},"staticQueryHashes":[]}